Lowy's great legacy – going Dutch
By Les Murray | 6 May 2008 | 10:43
This – the log in the computer tells me - is the 300th column I will write for this website.
Comments (35) | Your thoughts?
Time flies when you’re having fun. Or sit, day in and day out, hunched over a keyboard, in the end getting Repetitive Strain Injury (medical term) to the extent where your back muscles go into a spasm and you are forced to give half your salary to your physio so that you can continue to hunch and type, develop more RSI and give more to the physio.
In any case, such landmarks give cause for some natural reflection and, in this case, consider all that has happened since the hunching began.
In May 2000, when The World Game was launched, Frank Farina was our national coach, Basil Scarsella was chairman of Soccer Australia and the NSL was seen as a decaying competition, despite that month’s memorable grand final between Perth Glory and the Wollongong Wolves in front of a record 43,000.
Well, baby, look at the game now.
In one of the early columns, filed in July, 2000, I reviewed Euro 2000, lamenting the fact that three of the four semi finalists of that tournament – Italy, Portugal and France – were from the southern half of Europe, the half that is culturally bent towards treating football more like an art than as a sport.
The point of the column, however, was that the fourth semi finalist, Holland, despite being from the north, was not so dissimilar from the other three in its cultured style and technical approach, except for the fact that the Dutch played that way not by cultural blueprint but by pragmatic calculation.
The implication for Australia, argued the column, was that if the Dutch could acquire and import this kind of emphasis on skill and creativity, then surely so could we, as a country with a football heritage of wooden technique, rolled up sleeves and muscle - which was pretty much the Dutch way pre Rinus Michels, Johan Cruyff, Total Football and all of that.
Eight years on we have had two Dutch national coaches (plus a third, Dick Advocaat, who reneged, and chased another two, Leo Beenhakker and Louis van Gaal), and a Dutch technical director.
The Dutch technical ideology, and all strength to it, has permeated our game, right down to the boot straps of our six-year-olds who are now playing small sided games. The gold in the green and gold has taken on a decidedly orange hue.
The Olyroos, under a self-confessed Hiddink-disciple, are playing the Dutch way and Rob Baan, our Dutch TD, is mandated to ensure that the same ideological line is followed with the younger national teams.
We now even are to have an under-14 national boys team, a Baan initiative, and you can guess what technical culture they will be playing under.
Johnny Warren, who was still very much alive in 2000, would scarcely believe all this now, that all this could happen in such a short time span, but he would surely be pleased. He only ever said that we should learn from the best and that, at last, is what we are now trying to do.
At Euro 2000 the Dutch national coach, Frank Rijkaard, nobly resigned after Holland lost its luckless semi final to Italy in a penalty shootout. Two years later he took over at FC Barcelona and led them to be the most admired club team in the world, not just because of their results, which were impressive, but because of the way they achieved them.
Six years on he is still there. He won’t last it seems because the power of the dressing room, inhabited by millionaire players as petulant as they are rich, has weighed him down. But even on the eve of his departure, with all the dressing room turbulence, with no Ronaldinho, his Barca still managed to completely outplay Manchester United over two legs of the Champions League semi finals.
United, who are now in the final in Moscow on May 21, went to the Nou Camp and cowered like wimps in the first leg. Barca went to Old Trafford and did the opposite in the return, dominating the game, but still lost, though only barely after a Zambrotta mental block and a Scholes king hit.
The Dutch way, part of whose credo is to dictate play through ball possession and attack with conviction, is still the best way and it remains the best model for Australia.
The Dutch imprint on Australian football only began with Guus Hiddink in 2005. And Hiddink, let’s be honest, was not appointed because he was Dutch, or because of any broader desire to import Dutch football methods, but because he was both immensely successful and available.
Hiddink went on to completely transform the Australian team’s way of playing, led it to a successful World Cup, and the penny dropped.
We have been going orange ever since. And the conclusion that going Dutch may be a good thing, arrived at by pure accident thanks to the Hiddink appointment, may be the greatest legacy of the Lowy years.
Of course some of us knew that we could have done this a lot earlier, like 30 years ago, but I guess it’s better late then never.
Join the Discussion
PLEASE NOTE: All submitted comments become the property of SBS. We reserve the right to edit and/or amend submitted comments. HTML tags other than paragraph, line break, bold or italics will be removed from your comment.
Your Comments
12 May 2008 13:52 AEST
From: newcastle
Absolutely Les, I agree wholeheartedly. I play in the church comp in Newcastle in Div 2. As you can imagine, a lot of the time most guys just "kick and hope" and rush, rush, rush to get the ball forward as fast as you can. At this level, you expect it. Then I see the Under 19's etc playing almost the same style for large portions of the game and I just shake my head in dismay. Then I realise its not really their fault. They have been coached this way since being kids. Fix the coaching I say.
I agree (0 agree) I disagree (0 disagree)
11 May 2008 23:32 AEST
From: Melbourne
I agree with everything you say Les although once again one of the boys from TWG is having a go at a premier league team. Man utd went to barca to try and close the game as they knew they had the second game at home still to play. Sure it may not have been the best game of football but it was the game Man Utd needed to play to reach the final. In the second leg Man Utd had many chances to score as did Barca but the better team over to 2 legs went through. Im over the paying out on English teams.
I agree (0 agree) I disagree (0 disagree)
09 May 2008 14:41 AEST
From: Bunbury
By all means use the Dutch model as a framework for the development of our game but remain highly critical of the practitioners. Lets not assume that all that is Dutch is good. If we can share their vision of a team that plays total football, be adept at possession and attack with purpose that will be enough. The strategies that we implement to achieve that vision, 30 years since Johan Cruyff strode the pitch like a colossus, will be our own, not Dutch.
I agree (0 agree) I disagree (0 disagree)
09 May 2008 12:49 AEST
From: Sydney
The emphahsis on top to bottom Dutch style misses one important level, the A-League clubs.
I agree (0 agree) I disagree (0 disagree)
09 May 2008 9:28 AEST
From: Sydney
Ive been an Ajax fan for years, the dutch have a proven system and while not winning everything they do produce many talented footballers that go on to great things. Our kids need to be coached in a way that allows them to express themselves (skills) without being belittled for it as well as being able to play multiple positions. I get tired of hearing parents complain because junior is playing out of position. Kids need to play all positions they become more useful and can adapt .
I agree (0 agree) I disagree (0 disagree)
08 May 2008 18:35 AEST
From: NSW
Les i agree. But the problem is there is so much conflict with style in Australian football. To me it seems the people who want Australian football to succeed are trying dearly to orchestrate not just a Dutch style but a possession-based style and teach this to our footballers. But there is another faction that keeps emphasising being strong, playing fast and long balls is what is necessary... that what is replicated by the EPL lower teams. Many a-league coaches are still playing longball.
I agree (0 agree) I disagree (0 disagree)
08 May 2008 14:42 AEST
From: Melbourne
Australia has never played Dutch-style football. It only benefited from a master coach like Hiddink who was able to organize our WC squad in 2006. It would be a total lack of respect to the great Dutch sides of the past to even think that we did. We could've played Italy for three days and not scored. You can hardly expect Australian players to 'play Dutch' for the Socceroos just because there is a Dutch coach at the helm. How many Dutch coaches are there at your junior club? That's the real problem.
I agree (0 agree) I disagree (0 disagree)
08 May 2008 13:40 AEST
From: Sydney
To everyone in this blog who points towards Holland's poor results, i would say that regularly reaching Qtr, Semi and finals of the Euros and World Cup for a country with a population smaller than ours is something that we can only aspire to achieve let alone emulate. For a country with such a small population to pick from they have a fantastic record, they are not exactly losers. Football is very competitive and very few countries actually win the world cup especially the ones with no history.
I agree (0 agree) I disagree (0 disagree)
07 May 2008 8:23 AEST
From: Sydney
I don't think there's a problem with one country taking most of its developmental cues from a more "established" football nation, like Japan do with Brazil and China with Serbia. The Dutch may not have been roaring successes at full NT level over the last thirty years, but their record in developing quality young players (not just Dutchmen, incidentally) is undeniable. The only danger is that this new Dutch interest might engender a sort of Eric Worthington-style jobs-for-the-boys situation.
I agree (0 agree) I disagree (0 disagree)
Les Murray
Recent Posts
- Will Big Phil bring back sexy football?
- Ronaldo, the millionaire slave
- Dukes, our last number nine
- Viva Espana, viva football
- Why Euro is 'counter' productive
ADVERTISEMENT
Blogs
Why Olympic obsession is driving Brazil nuts
There is only one thing Brazilians detest more than missing out on a football trophy ... it's losing it to bitter rivals Argentina.
Will Big Phil bring back sexy football?
There could only have been one reason why Roman Abramovich chose Luiz Felipe Scolari as Chelsea's coach. Well, actually two.
Aussie coaches' interests not served by handout culture
Interesting story this morning reporting that David Mitchell, coach of Perth Glory, is calling for Football Federation Australia and the Rudd Government to fund a program for Australian coaches wanting to work in Asia.
The untapped Asian market
It's a question that I've raised countless times before but unfortunately one that again needs asking. Why has the A-League continued to shun its own backyard and refused to embrace Asia?
Your Views
Josh Kennedy was lethal against Qatar. He gets better by the season. We are yet to see his best...
Says Lou on Kennedy keeps flame alive
Launch playerVideos
![play [Paulo Wanchope scores wonder goal]](http://videocdn.sbs.com.au/u/thumbnails/EPL_HGH_Paulo_Wanchope_score_6_16600.jpg)

-
Paulo Wanchope scores wonder goal
21 Jul 08 | 00:00:57.0
![play [Paolo Di Canio's Sportsmanship]](http://videocdn.sbs.com.au/u/thumbnails/EPL_HGH_Paolo_Di_Canios_Spo_6_16596.jpg)

-
Paolo Di Canio's Sportsmanship
21 Jul 08 | 00:01:01.0
![play [THE SPECIAL ONE - SVEN'S ASSIGNMENT]](http://videocdn.sbs.com.au/u/thumbnails/EPL_HGH_THE_SPECIAL_ONE_SV_6_17270.jpg)

-
THE SPECIAL ONE - SVEN'S ASSIGNMENT
20 Jul 08 | 00:04:50.0
![play [Classic Match - Liverpool v Newcastle]](http://videocdn.sbs.com.au/u/thumbnails/EPL_HGH_Classic_Match_Live_6_16592.jpg)

-
Classic Match - Liverpool v Newcastle
14 Jul 08 | 00:01:00.0
![play [Alan Shearer Player of the Decade]](http://videocdn.sbs.com.au/u/thumbnails/EPL_HGH_Alan_Shearer_Player__6_16588.jpg)

-
Alan Shearer Player of the Decade
10 Jul 08 | 00:01:00.0
![play [Fabrizio Ravanelli's sudden impact]](http://videocdn.sbs.com.au/u/thumbnails/EPL_HGH_Fabrizio_Ravanellis_6_16527.jpg)

-
Fabrizio Ravanelli's sudden impact
09 Jul 08 | 00:01:00.0
![play [Sheringham scores first televised goal]](http://videocdn.sbs.com.au/u/thumbnails/EPL_HGH_Sheringham_scores_fi_6_16526.jpg)

-
Sheringham scores first televised goal
09 Jul 08 | 00:01:01.0
![play [THE SPECIAL ONE The love bucket]](http://videocdn.sbs.com.au/u/thumbnails/EPL_HGH_THE_SPECIAL_ONE_6_16352.jpg)

-
THE SPECIAL ONE The love bucket
06 Jul 08 | 00:04:54.0
![play [The Special One 150 million hits]](http://videocdn.sbs.com.au/u/thumbnails/TWG_GG_The_Special_One_150__6_13719.jpg)

-
The Special One 150 million hits
18 May 08 | 00:04:40.0
![play [THE SPECIAL ONE no friend like Sven]](http://videocdn.sbs.com.au/u/thumbnails/TWG_GG_THE_SPECIAL_ONE_no_f_6_13360.jpg)

-
THE SPECIAL ONE no friend like Sven
11 May 08 | 00:03:17.0
![play [THE SPECIAL ONE Is 'It' finished]](http://videocdn.sbs.com.au/u/thumbnails/TWG_GG_THE_SPECIAL_ONE_it_6_13023.jpg)

-
THE SPECIAL ONE Is 'It' finished
04 May 08 | 00:05:30.0
![play [THE SPECIAL ONE Lol'ing and Rofl'ing]](http://videocdn.sbs.com.au/u/thumbnails/TWG_GG_THE_SPECIAL_ONE_Lol_6_12578.jpg)

-
THE SPECIAL ONE Lol'ing and Rofl'ing
27 Apr 08 | 00:05:27.0
![play [THE SPECIAL ONE Sven the Imposter]](http://videocdn.sbs.com.au/u/thumbnails/TWG_GG_THE_SPECIAL_ONE_Sven_6_12220.jpg)

-
THE SPECIAL ONE Sven the Imposter
21 Apr 08 | 00:05:10.0
![play [STOPPAGE TIME Hemisphere Logic]](http://videocdn.sbs.com.au/u/thumbnails/TWG_EXP_STOPPAGE_TIME_Hemisp_6_14604.jpg)

-
STOPPAGE TIME Hemisphere Logic
02 Jun 08 | 00:02:05.0
![play [SHOOTOUT Premier League Special ]](http://videocdn.sbs.com.au/u/thumbnails/EXP_SHOOTOUT_Premier_6_1029.jpg)

-
SHOOTOUT Premier League Special
24 Oct 07 | 00:08:13.0
![play [KIDS FC - Australian Football Skool]](http://videocdn.sbs.com.au/u/thumbnails/TWG_AF_KIDS_FC_Australian_6_17243.jpg)

-
KIDS FC - Australian Football Skool
20 Jul 08 | 00:03:18.0
![play [A-League Vidmars double trouble]](http://videocdn.sbs.com.au/u/thumbnails/TWG_AF_ALeague_Vidmars_dou_6_16946.jpg)

-
A-League Vidmars double trouble
15 Jul 08 | 00:03:06.0
![play [A-League Glory days ahead for Mitch]](http://videocdn.sbs.com.au/u/thumbnails/TWG_AF_ALeague_Glory_days__6_16945.jpg)

-
A-League Glory days ahead for Mitch
15 Jul 08 | 00:02:54.0
![play [OLYROOS Bridge keen as mustard]](http://videocdn.sbs.com.au/u/thumbnails/TWG_AF_OLYROOS_Bridge_keen__6_16663.jpg)

-
OLYROOS Bridge keen as mustard
11 Jul 08 | 00:01:57.0
![play [OLYROOS Velaphi loves the round ball]](http://videocdn.sbs.com.au/u/thumbnails/TWG_AF_OLYROOS_Velaphi_love_6_16662.jpg)

-
OLYROOS Velaphi loves the round ball
11 Jul 08 | 00:01:17.0
![play [KIDS FC Football's healing power]](http://videocdn.sbs.com.au/u/thumbnails/TWG_AF_KIDS_FC_Footballs_h_6_14759.jpg)

-
KIDS FC Football's healing power
08 Jun 08 | 00:03:55.0
![play [DR JOSEPH VENGLOS AND ROB BAAN TALK SHOP]](http://videocdn.sbs.com.au/u/thumbnails/TWG_EXP_FFA_NATIONAL_COACHIN_9999_14565.jpg)

-
DR JOSEPH VENGLOS AND ROB BAAN TALK SHOP
01 Jun 08 | 00:00:50.0
![play [Kids FC Emily Van Egmond profile]](http://videocdn.sbs.com.au/u/thumbnails/TWG_AF_Kids_FC_Emily_Van_Eg_6_14057.jpg)

-
Kids FC Emily Van Egmond profile
23 May 08 | 00:03:13.0
![play [KIDS FC - Kelvin Grove College]](http://videocdn.sbs.com.au/u/thumbnails/TWG_AF_KIDS_FC_Kelvin_Gro_6_13232.jpg)

-
KIDS FC - Kelvin Grove College
08 May 08 | 00:03:10.0

30 May 2008 10:20 AEST
Chris Saville
From: Coldstream Vic
I hate to go against the crowd but im sorry this dutch way is an improvement but im not sure its the right way. We have always focused on our negatives and I think this dutch way is strong defensivly just in case we lose the ball with a sloppy touch or pass.Australia should be focusing on how athletic our players are we can chase the ball down after losing it our players are blessed with hunger I believe we should be following the french or recent german coaches in attack.
I agree (0 agree) I disagree (0 disagree)